List of original members from Sept 3, 1834 –
 The Evangelical Congregational Church in North Andover
Ezra Abbott 2nd
Timothy Abbott
Ruth (Bradley) Barker (Mrs. Joshua) South Church, Andover
Seth Burnham
Emeline (Hennenway) Clark (Mrs. Ezra) Church in Framingham
Joseph Cummings South Church, Andover
Mary Plummer (Poor)(Step) Cummings (Mrs. Joseph) South Church, Andover
Jedediah Farnham – Deacon First Church North Andover
Lavinia Farnham (Daughter of Jedediah) 1st Church N. Yarmouth, Maine
Susan (Johnson) Farnham (Daughter of Jedediah) First Church North Andover
Lydia Foster Church in West Boxford
Mehitable Foster Church in West Boxford
Rebecca Foster Church in West Boxford
Sarah Foster Church in West Boxford
Phoebe Johnson (Farnham) Gilbert (Mrs. George H) Confirmation of Faith
David Gray Jr. South Church, Andover
Sarah (Pears) Gray (Mrs. David Jr) South Church, Andover
Aaron Henry – Deacon Church at Johnson, NH
Miriam (Hubbard) Henry Church at Johnson, NH
Albert Hervey – Deacon South Church, Andover
Susan (Frye) Hinchcliffe (Mrs. John) First Church North Andover
Mary Johnson First Church North Andover
Sally Johnson First Church North Andover
Mary Holt (Adams) Lord (Mrs. Nathl. Jr) South Church, Andover
Hannah (Porter) Osgood (Mrs. Peter) First Church North Andover
Hannah Porter Osgood (Daughter of Peter) First Church North Andover
Joseph Peters
Catherine (Johnson) Pierce (Mrs. Jesse) Church in Williamstown
Jesse Pierce – Deacon Church in Williamstown
Joseph Poor
Dolly (Farnham) Spofford (Mrs. Moody) First Church North Andover
Sally (Carlton) Stacy (Mrs. Timothy) Church at Lamphrey River, NH
Timothy Stacy Church at Lamphrey River, NH
Elizabeth Stevens South Church, Andover
Phebe (Fitch) Tyler (Mrs. Job) First Church North Andover
Anna Upton First Church North Andover